Gareth SchuthHeadmaster:  Mr. Gareth Schuth

Mr. Schuth is a 2005 Messiah College graduate with a BS in Music Education. After teaching music in public school and tutoring students in Math, he discovered his love of teaching Math. This led to adding Math and Science credentials to his PA Teaching Certificate. He is excited to share his knowledge and love of these subjects with his students. “Helping transform young minds to the likeness of Christ takes time, effort and love.”

In addition to his duties as Headmaster, Mr. Schuth teaches 6th-8th grade Math. Gareth and his wife, Annie, are members of Grace Baptist Church and have three children.


School Secretary: Mrs. Allison Stine

Mrs. Stine serves as the school secretary and assists the Headmaster in many of his administrative duties. She also assists with athletic scheduling, yearbook editing, and provides first aid to the students.

Allison earned her bachelor’s degree from Penn State University and later received a MS in Counseling from Shippensburg University. She has two children and is a member of the Carlisle Evangelical Free Church.


Nichelle MantiPre-Kindergarten:  Mrs. Nichelle Manti

Mrs. Manti is the teacher of our first Pre-K.  She is a graduate of Oregon State University and has a BS in Family Sciences.  Nichelle and her husband Seth have three daughters and are members of Resonate Community Church.  Nichelle brings six years of prior experience in a Pre-K setting.




Amanda BeardmorePre-Kindergarten Classroom Aide:  Amanda Beardmore

Mrs. Beardmore is a Medical Assistant and graduate of Sussex County Community College.  Amanda and her husband Aaron have three children and are members of Grace Baptist Church.




Melanie EndresKindergarten: Mrs. Melanie Endres

Mrs. Endres is a graduate of Messiah College and has a BS in Elementary Education. Melanie taught 2nd grade at the Christian school 1995-1999, and has been teaching Kindergarten since 2011.

Melanie and her husband, Mike, have three children and are members of Grace Baptist Church.



Jan SpringerFirst Grade: Mrs. Jan Springer

Mrs. Springer provides a great foundation to our first graders in reading, phonics, grammar, and math.  The students are challenged and encouraged to develop their minds for the glory of God each day. Mrs. Springer has a B.A. in Elementary Education from Shippensburg University and has advanced training in Reading development.  Through the years she has provided many families with individual tutoring for students with reading difficulties.  She is married, with three children and is a member of Grace Baptist Church.



Susanne HarrisSecond Grade: Mrs. Susanne Harris

Mrs. Harris is a 1986 Shippensburg University graduate with a BS in Elementary Education.  She has taught various grade levels including four years here at Grace Baptist Christian School (1990-1994) in first grade.

Susanne and her husband, Craig, live in Chambersburg where he pastors Grace Baptist Church.  They have two children.


Third Grade Grammar, Science and Social Studies:  Mrs. Christy Wiedman

Mrs. Wiedman holds a BA in Bible and Elementary Education from Baptist Bible College.  Mrs. Wiedman taught 2nd Grade from 1992-1995 and 4th Grade from 1999-2000 at West Shore Christian School.

Christy has seven children.  She and her husband, Eric, are currently in the new members class of the West Shore Evangelical Free Church.


Michael Endres

Third Grade Bible, Math, Spelling, Reading, and Grades 1-8 Technology Coordinator: Mr. Mike Endres

Mr. Endres received his Bachelor degree from Messiah College and joined the faculty in 1999 after completing his Master’s degree from Shippensburg University in Special Education. He is the Computer Lab teacher for grades 1-8, teaches 3rd grade, coaches boys soccer and directs the Boy’s Ensemble.

He is married to Kindergarten teacher, Melanie, and has three children. Mike and Melanie are members of Grace Baptist Church.


Fourth Grade: Miss Katie Nolte

Miss Nolte is a 2018 graduate of Grove City College. She spent her entire school career in the Christian School system, graduating from Denbigh Baptist Christian School in Newport News, VA. In addition to her student teaching in public schools she has spent summers working in a Christian day care and pre-school. She is currently a member of Denbigh Baptist Church and teaches 4th grade.


Fifth Grade: Miss Angie Tonkin

Miss Tonkin attended the Christian School of Grace Baptist Church, graduating with the class of 2008. Miss Tonkin is also a graduate of West Shore Christian High School and Liberty University. She also brings to our staff prior coaching experience and leads a young adult Bible Study at the Carlisle Evangelical Free Church, where she is a member. She teaches 5th grade and 5th & 6th Geography and Science.


Sara Leone6th Literature, 7th & 8th Grammar, and 7th & 8th Spanish: Mrs. Sara Leone

Mrs. Leone attended The Christian School of Grace Baptist Church from Kindergarten through eighth grade.  In 1987 she received her Bachelor of Arts degree from Grove City College. She has taught various grade levels in Christian schools in Illinois and Pennsylvania, including a year of beginning Spanish here at Grace Baptist Christian School (1999-2000). From 2000 to 2005 she home schooled her children in rural Georgia. She currently teaches 7th & 8th Grade Spanish, 7th & 8th Grade Grammar, and 6th Grade Literature.

In 2007 Banner of Truth Trust published Mrs. Leone’s book on the responsibilities of pastors’ wives entitled, Her Husband’s Crown – A Wife’s Ministry and a Minister’s Wife. She and her husband Scott have three children and are members of Bible Baptist Church in Shiremanstown, PA. Her hobbies include reading, crocheting, piano playing, and family history.


6th-8th Grade Bible, 6th Grade Grammar, 7th & 8th Grade History and Literature, 5th-8th Grade PE:
Mr. Andrew Nedimyer

Mr. Nedimyer is a graduate of Houghton college. He spent several years with the Air Force reserves before taking a teaching position in Maryland. He has several years of secondary teaching and coaching experience. Andrew and his wife have two children and are members of Grace Baptist Church. He teaches 6th-8th grade Bible, 6th Grade Grammar, 7th & 8th Grade History and Literature, and 5th-8th Grade PE.


Carol GarmanMusic: Mrs. Carol Garman

Mrs. Garman is a 1979 Geneva College graduate with a degree in Elementary Education and a concentration in music. Prior to her marriage, Mrs. Garman taught 2nd grade in The Christian School from 1979-80, 2nd and 3rd grade from 1980-81, and 2nd grade from 1981-1984. She is a past member of the Genevans Concert Choir and Madrigals, and she traveled with the Continental Singers for one summer singing in Holland, Germany and Poland. She has served in the Christian School as a music substitute for several years as well as accompanist and music coach.

Mrs. Garman returned to The Christian School as music teacher in 2002 providing music instruction to grades 1 through 8. She directs the middle school choir, Girls’ Ensemble, and Grace Notes. Her duties include planning and directing the music portion of school programs, and preparing students for annual music competitions. Phil and Carol Garman have three children and are members of Grace Baptist Church.


Art: Mrs. Trude Brummer

Mrs. Brummer has a bachelors degree from Shippensburg University in Art & Communications Journalism. She has been a substitute teacher for the school for several years and will now be using her graphic arts experience as she teaches 1st-6th Grade Art.

Trude and her husband have two children and are currently in the new members class at the Carlisle Evangelical Free Church.